Greenlight Turns Red: US SEC Warns Ethereum and Solana Staking ETFs May Violate Federal Law

2025/06/02 16:43

关注

SEC Flags Legal Hurdles For Ethereum And Solana ETFs With Staking Features

Two asset managers are facing new scrutiny from U.S. regulators over their plans to introduce cryptocurrency exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that offer staking rewards.

Despite initial approval, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) is questioning whether these products meet the legal definition required to be listed as ETFs under federal law.

Are These Crypto Funds Actually Investment Companies?

REX Financial and Osprey Funds had secured what they believed was the green light to launch Ethereum and Solana ETFs that include staking exposure—allowing investors to earn rewards by helping maintain blockchain operations.

But just hours after their registration became effective on 30 May, SEC staff raised concerns in a formal letter to ETF Opportunities Trust, the legal issuer of the funds.

⚡ ICYMI: 🇺🇸 SEC questions legality of new staking-based crypto ETFs

The Commission told ETF Opportunities Trust — the entity responsible for registering funds managed by REX Financial and Osprey Funds — that the new $ETH and $SOL staking ETFs may not qualify as legal… pic.twitter.com/F5VcXAkBl7
— CryptosRus (@CryptosR_Us) June 1, 2025

According to the SEC, the ETFs may not qualify as investment companies under the Investment Company Act of 1940, a status that is mandatory for listing on public exchanges.

The agency pointed out that the funds “improperly filed their registration statement” using Form N-1A and said their disclosures “may be potentially misleading.”

Staking In Etfs Sparks Regulatory Tension

The core issue lies in the ETFs’ staking feature.

The SEC remains uncertain whether funds that generate returns through staking can be considered to be “primarily engaged in investing in securities,” which is central to being recognised as an investment company.

Under U.S. law, an entity is considered an investment company if more than 40% of its assets consist of investment securities or if its main business involves investing or trading securities.

⚖️ 3(c)(1) - The “100 Investor” Exemption

This exemption limits the number of investors to 100, making it ideal for smaller funds. But counting investors can get tricky, especially with LLCs or fund-of-funds structures. Be mindful of how you count investors. pic.twitter.com/kgdqgnuI5Q
— The Investments Lawyers (TIL) (@Tillawfirm) May 30, 2025

REX general counsel Greg Collett said the firm is aware of the concerns and intends to address them before listing.

He told Bloomberg,

“We think we can satisfy the SEC on the investment company question, and we don’t intend to launch the funds until we do that.”

Crypto-Friendly Policies Face Internal Pushback

While the SEC under President Donald Trump’s administration has eased pressure on the crypto sector—dropping or pausing several lawsuits, including one involving Binance and its founder Changpeng Zhao—internal disagreements remain.

Commissioner Caroline Crenshaw, the commission’s only Democrat, criticised the agency’s inconsistent messaging on what qualifies as a security.

Crenshaw said in a statement on 31 May,

“How is it that these crypto assets are supposedly not securities when it comes to registration requirements, but conveniently are securities when a registrant sees an opportunity to sell a new product? If you’re confused, join the club.”

The comment follows new staff guidance released on 29 May clarifying that certain types of staking—such as self-staking and custodial staking—do not constitute the sale of securities.

Though not legally binding, the guidance represents a notable shift from the SEC’s prior enforcement tone.

Staking Etfs May Still Have A Future

REX received effective registration for its Ethereum and Solana ETFs on 30 May, just ahead of the SEC’s objections.

REX founder Greg King had said the company intended to launch both funds by mid-June.

The registration also included ETFs linked to other digital assets such as Bitcoin, XRP, Dogecoin, and even the TRUMP meme coin.

🚨 New Effective Date Set: June 13, 2025

The SEC filing confirms a new effective date for the REX-OSPREY™ ETFs, including:

📈 $TRUMP
💰 $BTC
💸 $XRP
🔥 $BONK
🐶 $DOGE
💣 $XRP

Filed under Rule 485(b) — Amendment No. 213 now takes effect 6/13/25.#ETFs #XRP #BTC #DOGE #BONK pic.twitter.com/UEaHviMo6G
— XRPArmy (@Mullen_Army) May 29, 2025

Despite regulatory uncertainty, analysts remain optimistic.

James Seyffart, ETF analyst at Bloomberg Intelligence, said,

“Even if the SEC doesn’t allow this structure to list, we still believe the more straightforward attempts to allow staking in a U.S. ETF will ultimately be successful. It’s a matter of when, not if. But the SEC doesn’t seem to be a fan of the way REX tried to push these listings through.”

The SEC has said that unless the concerns are resolved, its staff will consider “appropriate next steps” to enforce compliance with securities laws.

了解更多行业报道，与作者、读者更深入探讨、交流，欢迎加入Coinlive社群：https://t.me/CoinliveSG

添加评论

登录留下您的精彩评论……

0 评论

最早的

加载更多评论

Greenlight Turns Red: US SEC Warns Ethereum and Solana Staking ETFs May Violate Federal Law

SEC Flags Legal Hurdles For Ethereum And Solana ETFs With Staking Features

Are These Crypto Funds Actually Investment Companies?

Staking In Etfs Sparks Regulatory Tension

Crypto-Friendly Policies Face Internal Pushback

Staking Etfs May Still Have A Future

相关资讯

中国矿池大佬“神鱼”证实12083枚以太坊被盗！价值2亿元人民币

价值20亿美元的ETH从与plustoken相关的钱包转移，疑似案件主要罪犯出狱所导致

随着现货 ETH ETF 上市的脚步越来越近，以太坊反弹即将到来，Whale 转移了价值 5000 万美元的以太坊

距离上次发行不到一个月，USDC 财政部在 Solana 网络上再度发行 2.5 亿 USDC

加密货币市场血雨腥风，比特币跌破55000美元支撑位！Mt. Gox还款计划引发连锁反应

VanEck 表示只要任命新的 SEC 主席，Solana ETF 就能获得批准，这是在为特朗普拉票？

Solana即将迎来飙升？VanEck 已申请基于 Solana 的基金

美国通胀数据公布后，比特币飙升至 69,000 美元以上

美国通胀数据公布：比特币一路飙升至6.9万美元以上

索拉纳基金会因三明治攻击零售商而罢免验证员

实时更新

热门资讯

Amalgam Founder Faces Legal Fallout After Allegedly Luring Investors into $1 Million Scam Based on Bogus Blockchain

Build Online Shops Using Prompts: Shopify’s New AI Features Let Merchants Build, Customise, and Manage Stores Without Writing a Single Line of Code

Crypto.com Deepens European Presence with MiFID License to Offer Crypto Derivatives

Huge Investment, No Results: Microsoft-Backed Builder.ai Forced Into Bankruptcy After Creditor Seizes $37M — Was The Startup’s Hype A Lie From the Start?

Global Cyber Crackdown: Microsoft Secures Court Order, Seizes 2,300 Domains to Shut Down Lumma Stealer Targeting Nearly 400,000 Windows Devices

AI in Your Pocket: OpenAI Is Building Tiny Companions with AI Capabilities and Plans to Ship 100 Million of Them

The Stock Market Never Sleeps—Crypto Exchange Kraken to Launch 24/7 Trading of Apple, Tesla and 50+ U.S. Stocks on Solana

Dribbling into the Digital Age: FIFA Drafts Avalanche to Power Its FIFA Blockchain for Next-Gen Fan Experiences

Singapore’s Crypto Awareness Peaks at 94%, Yet Ownership Lags at 29% — Why is its Holding Rate Falling Despite Its Hub Status?

Solana’s First Branded Hardware Wallet: Ledger Rolls Out Ecosystem-Tailored Device with Soulbound Identity Token and Exclusive Community Perks